UK-registered +44 7367 067226
WhatsApp FOLLOW f in X
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Why Do We Always End Up Short in Some Sizes and Overcut in Others?
Problems We Solve

Why Do We Always End Up Short in Some Sizes and Overcut in Others?

Cut plans worked out by hand from a PO's size breakdown leave garment factories short or overcut. We build a cut planner that turns orders into lays and ratios.

Updated 3 min readBy SpiderHunts Technologies

Free estimateNo obligation

Get a free estimate

Tell us what you need. A senior engineer reads every enquiry.

Takes under a minute. We never share your details.

  • Free consultation
  • No commitment
  • NDA on request

Prefer to talk? Book a free 30-minute call →

Quick answer: TL;DR

Size shortages and overcuts come from cut plans worked out by hand on a calculator, where the order breakdown, the marker ratios and the lay limits never meet in one place. We build a cut order planner that takes the size and colour breakdown from the purchase order, proposes lays and ratios within your table length and ply limits, and tracks cut quantities back against the order.

Twelve short in size 16, forty over in size 10

The purchase order is for 2,400 dresses across three colours and six sizes, with the brand's usual heavy weighting in 10, 12 and 14. The cutting manager works out the lays with a calculator and a pad: two markers, a ratio of 1-2-2-2-1-1, so many plies per colour. The numbers look right. At packing, size 16 in the floral print is twelve short and there are forty extra size 10s in black.

Somewhere between the order breakdown, the ratio, the plies and a lay that had to be cut short because a roll ran out, the arithmetic slipped. It usually does, a little, on most orders.

The plan is done where nobody can check it

Cut planning is a genuinely fiddly calculation, and the obvious answer is to be more careful. The actual trouble is that the plan lives on a pad, and what happens on the table afterwards is never reconciled with it.

  • The order breakdown is copied by hand from the brand's PO into the plan.
  • Ratios are chosen to suit the marker, then plies are worked out to hit the totals, with rounding at each step.
  • Table length and maximum ply height limit what can go in one lay, and those limits are in someone's head.
  • When a lay is changed on the day, the plan is not updated.
  • Cut quantities are counted at the bundle stage, if at all, and not compared with the order until packing.

What a wrong cut plan costs

Shortages in a size mean a small recut, which is expensive per garment, needs fabric that may already be used, and can hold up the whole shipment. Overcuts are fabric and labour you paid for and cannot invoice. On orders where the brand counts to the unit, both lead to awkward conversations and sometimes a claim. And the cutting manager spends hours on arithmetic that a computer does better.

A cut order planner that keeps the order in view

  1. The size and colour breakdown is taken from the brand's purchase order, read from the PDF or spreadsheet they send, and checked by a person before it is used.
  2. You set your constraints once: table lengths, maximum plies for each fabric type, typical marker widths and your normal cut allowance per size.
  3. The planner proposes lays with size ratios and ply counts that meet the order within those limits, showing the expected quantity per size against what was ordered.
  4. The cutting manager can adjust the proposal, for example to reuse a marker that already exists in Gerber or Lectra, and see the effect on each size immediately.
  5. As each lay is cut, the actual plies are recorded and the planner updates what remains to be cut, so a short lay is made up in the next one.
  6. Cut quantities per size and colour flow on to the bundle stage and, at the end, are reconciled with packed and shipped quantities.
StepPad and calculatorCut planner
Order breakdownCopied by handRead from the PO, then checked
Ratios and pliesWorked out, rounded at each stepProposed within your limits
Lay changed on the dayPlan not updatedRemaining quantities recalculated
End of orderCount at packingCut, packed and shipped reconciled

A cutting room with the numbers in front of it

The cutting manager starts from a proposed plan and spends time on the judgement calls: which fabric shrinks, which marker is worth reusing, which size the brand always adds to later. When a lay comes up short, the next lay absorbs it without a recount. Shortages are found when there is still fabric on the roll, rather than at the packing table.

Is this your packing table?

  • Orders regularly ship short in one or two sizes.
  • You have overcut stock you cannot sell back to the brand.
  • Cut plans are worked out on paper by one person.
  • Changes to a lay on the day are not written down.
  • Cut quantities are only compared with the order at the end.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

The questions readers ask us after this guide.

Still have a question?

Ask us directly. A senior engineer reads every question.

Ask about your project

Does the planner create markers?

No. Markers stay in your CAD system. The planner works out ratios, lays and ply counts, and can reuse the marker ratios you already have.

Can it handle a brand that adds sizes after the order is placed?

Yes. An amended breakdown updates what remains to be cut, and the planner shows the effect before the next lay goes down.

What if our cutting manager disagrees with the plan?

They change it. The planner shows the consequences of each change per size, but the decision stays with the person who knows the fabric.

What does it need to connect to?

At minimum, the purchase orders. It can also pass cut quantities to your bundle tracking or ERP if you have one.

What drives the cost?

How many brands' PO formats need reading, whether cut quantities are entered by hand or scanned, and what other systems need the results.

Keep reading

More on Problems We Solve

Start here

Tell us where the paperwork slows your factory floor

Describe the brands you make for, how orders reach the cutting room, and how the lines are tracked and paid today. We will tell you what we would build and what we would leave alone, and if a change to the way you already work would fix it, we will say so.

  1. You tell us what you needTwo minutes on the form, or a message on WhatsApp.
  2. A senior engineer reviews itAnd comes back with questions, a realistic range and an honest view on fit.
  3. Free 30-minute scoping callWe talk through scope, options and a realistic estimate, with no obligation.
Free estimateNo obligation

Talk to someone who builds this

Send a short brief and we will come back with an honest view and a realistic range.

Takes under a minute. We never share your details.

  • Free consultation
  • No commitment
  • NDA on request

Prefer to talk? Book a free 30-minute call →