Which Model Should Your Application Use?
Last updated:
The question assumes a single answer
“Which model is best” presumes one workload. Most business applications involve several tasks — classification, extraction, retrieval, generation — and those want different models.
The productive question is: for each step, what is the cheapest model that meets the quality bar for that step?
Routing by difficulty
| Task | Tier | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Classification, routing | Small and fast | Simple decisions, high volume |
| Extraction | Small to mid | Structured output, easily verified |
| Answering from context | Mid | Comprehension rather than deep reasoning |
| Drafting for review | Mid to large | Quality is visible to the reader |
| Multi-step reasoning | Large | Planning quality determines the outcome |
Test on your data, not on benchmarks
Public benchmarks measure general capability and correlate loosely with performance on your specific job. A few hundred of your own cases with agreed answers settles the question in an afternoon.
That set is also what lets you switch models later without re-testing everything by hand, which matters because better and cheaper options appear every few months.
Design for replacement
- Prompts in configuration, not scattered through code
- The provider abstracted behind a thin interface
- No dependence on provider-specific quirks unless the benefit is large
- The evaluation set rerun automatically on any model change
Latency is a product decision
A user waiting has a different tolerance from a background job. Interactive features need fast first tokens and benefit from streaming; batch processing can use slower, cheaper, stronger models.
Decide the latency budget per feature before choosing, because it eliminates options quickly and prevents a late redesign.
Frequently asked questions
Should we always use the newest model?
How often should we review the choice?
Is it worth using two providers?
How do we compare cost fairly?
Paying top-tier prices for simple classification?
Routing by difficulty often halves an AI bill. Tell us what your feature does and we will look at where it can be cheaper.
Related services
What we build for problems like this one